We're talking local beer from Western New YorkBuffalocal Blog

Craft BeerPerfect Pairings: Buffalocal Beer and Girl Scout Cookies

March 4, 2020by Buffalocal2

When March rolls around, Buffalonians know it’s time for Girl Scout Cookie orders to start arriving. As total beer lovers, we see no reason to set aside our pint glasses to indulge in our favorite cookies. Instead, we took our top 3 Girl Scout cookie flavors and found the perfect Buffalocal craft beers to pair with them!

1. Caramel DeLites

These shortbread cookies are topped with caramel, toasted coconut and fudge stripes. For a complimentary match, pair these decadent treats with a bock or Vienna lager whose malt bill will complement the sweetness and caramel notes found in the cookie. To contrast the sweetness, reach for a brown ale. The ale’s drier body and hops will hold up well against the sugars in the cookie for a bold and balanced tasting experience.

Buffalocal Picks: Resurgence Brewing Ice Boom Bock, Flying Bison Rusty Chain, Community Beer Works The Whale Brown Ale


2. Thin Mints

These crunchy chocolate wafers are bursting with mint flavor and covered in dark chocolate. Bold flavors like this call for a beer pairing that can match in intensity. The rich chocolate notes in a stout will perfectly amplify those found in the cookie while leaving room for the mint to shine through on the finish. To add some complexity, try a coffee porter whose roasted notes will contrast with the bold mint and chocolate.

Buffalocal Picks: Southern Tier NITRO Hot Cocoa, 12 Gates Coffee Porter  


3. Lemonades

These shortbread cookies have a tangy layer of lemon icing and a refreshing overall taste. A fruited sour will offer up a berry lemonade-like flavor explosion that is both sweet and tart. For a smoother option, grab a hefeweizen whose soft wheat body will round out some of the lemon notes. For a crisper option, reach for a Blonde Ale whose clean finish and light body will cut the richness of the buttery shortbread.

Buffalocal Picks: Big Ditch Berry Vision, 42 North Wallonia Wit, 12 Gates Yoga Pants

Which pairing are you most excited to try? Drop a line in the comments and let us know!


  • Paula Taton

    March 4, 2020 at 7:12 pm

    Do yourselves a favor – also try Berry Vision with peanut butter patties or s’mores. Life changing. Aviator Red or Buffalo Brewing’s Irish Red with peanut butter sandwich cookies is excellent too.


    • Buffalocal

      March 4, 2020 at 7:17 pm

      1000% Paula! We tried to keep this post shorter but Peanut Butter Patties and Berry Vision would be the adult adult equivalent of PB&J bliss! Thanks for the excellent suggestions. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *